Cast of Characters:



Karen
Enkidu (AKA Slim)
Beowolf (AKA Wolfie)
Blaze (AKA Blaze)

Thursday, September 04, 2008

The Evil Teachers' Union!

I was listening to part of the RNC on the radio and heard some guy shouting about the "liberal government" in Washington siding with the teachers' union and against the students. I'd like to take a moment to try to dispel some of the myths surrounding teachers and the union.

“School teachers only work part-time! Look, they have all summer off!”

On average, teachers work 186 days a year in the state of Oregon, of which 169 are spent teaching students. Some states require 180 school days.

A school teacher’s day looks something like this:

7:00-8:00 in school, available to students

8:00-12:00 teaching

12:00-12:30 lunch

12:30-3:00 teaching

3:00-4:00 in school, available to students

+2 hours of grading/lesson planning

That is an 11 hour day for a total of 1859 hours of work in the academic year, which divides out to 46.48 40 hour weeks of student contact per academic year. Additionally, there are the 17 days spent in teacher in-service and other duties, which add up to 136 hours if one assumes an 8 hour day; so another 3.4 40 hour work weeks. That sounds like full-time to me. Of course, that doesn’t include the time spent on required continuing education.

“School teachers are just babysitters!”


For comparison, let me also mention that my parents paid $9/day to my babysitter back in the early 90s. I have no idea what the going rate is, but we’ll go with that. If a teacher has a class of thirty and is ‘just a babysitter’, then that teacher should demand $270/day, which works out to $45,630 for 169 days. However, since a teacher also is to teach students, there is a certain value added.

“School teachers are just greedy and want too much money!”


A school teacher has gone to university for a minimum of 4 and often as many as 6 or 7 years. Generally, people who have gone to university for that long should be able to demand competitive salaries. Since teaching children is so important, it would seem logical that the people trained to do so would be very important to a society. If we want to have the best and the brightest instructing our children, then we need to provide a certain incentive for them to do so. If a person can’t make more as a teacher than as a secretary, where is the incentive? Teachers go into teaching because they enjoy teaching and want to help young people, not because they expect to become rich. However, they also need to have enough to feed their families and have health care so that they can devote their attention to doing their job, rather than to scraping to make ends meet. Also, as indicated above, teachers are professionals and should be paid professional salaries.


"Most money in the budget goes to paying teachers!"



Um, yes, the teachers need to eat. It is the teachers that make the entire enterprise possible. At minimum, a school needs students and teachers - a look at any third world country can tell us that much. We could do without the buildings and other accessories, but the teachers are absolutely necessary! This is not to say that we should stop maintaining the infrastructure, however, it is important to understand the vital role of teachers.


"The UNION!"



I would hope that teachers would be seen as allies in assuring a positive future for our children and, through them, our society. Teachers are workers just like just about everyone else. Teachers' unions are made up of teachers. A union is composed of individuals banding together to make sure that they are treated fairly and compensated for their labor. This doesn't make them evil! Also, many initiatives put forth by teachers' unions are aimed at helping further student education, so it is not only a benefit to the teachers, but also to the students.

------------------------------

Of course, I'm just preaching to the choir. Just about everyone who reads my blog on a regular basis already understands the value of education and the importance of attracting and maintaining qualified teachers.

2 comments:

The Frontline Coalition said...

Absolutely ridiculous. Teacher's by and large workhard. However, the problem isn't individual teachers, but the teacher's unions.

Unions fight for teacher's, not the students. Which makes sense since they are in fact a union. But the problem is that doesn't translate into quality education. Take tenure for example, an absurd concept. No other profession has guaranteed lifetime employment. Teacher's like anyone else should be required to work hard and achieve success, just like any other worker in a capitalist society.

It's clear our education system is broken. Charter schools, with non-unionized teacher's are making significant gains, demonstrating the success that can be achieved once unions are eliminated from the equation. In NYC, the charter schools in the poorest area of the city are outperforming every public school in the big apple.

The teacher union's ability to devastate our education system is not their only skill. They are also the root cause of crushing property taxes. Every year they demand more and more state aid, even though no correlation has ever been found that equates school spending and educational achievement.

But hey, what do I know. I'm just a lowly taxpayer who has worked within New York's broken state goverment. While you my friend, are a union hack.

Educate yourself.

www.TheFrontlineCoalition.com

-John Burke
TheFrontlineCoalition.com

Karen said...

Just to name a few, here are a few student-friendly / not specifically teacher oriented issues that the AFT is currently engaged with:

Child Labor
Civil Rights
English Language Learners
Training for Teaching Reading
Caring for Diabetic Students
Student with Autism
High School Graduation Rates
Student Accountability

Also, concerning property taxes, it may please you to know that teachers pay the same property taxes as everyone else.

I'm a socially conscious individual, who is a state employee and a taxpayer. The union is useful to me insofar as it aligns with my interests as concerns employment and social issues. I can guarantee that I would have missed many days of teaching if I hadn't had the medical care available to me because of the work of the union.

However, being a part of the union does not make me some sort of brainless follower. I participate in the union in activities that I approve of and decline those that do not interest me.

If that is the definition of a union hack, then I guess that's what I am.